Talk:Starships at Wolf 359
From Memory Alpha, the free Star Trek reference.
What's our stance on the two Melbournes? How/why were both there? My assumption (based on the additional presence of 'prototype' ships and a Constitution) is that ships at Utopia Planetia or another shipyard, in the process of decomissioning, were yanked from their scrapyard and pressed into service. Obviously, this is non-canon, so I haven't really stated it in specifics. -- DarkHorizon 13:48, 5 Jan 2004 (PST)
Strictly canonically speaking, the proto-Nebula Melbourne was neither named or really seen. I think the only really canon vessel is the Excelsior Melbourne, right? Or was there ever any really obvious evidence (as in: clear to the average viewer) to suggest otherwise? -- Harry 06:42, 6 Jan 2004 (PST)
[edit] About Klingons at Wolf 359
I decided to place this here because I honestly think there were no Klingons in Wolf 359, dispite what Unity says. I have asked numerous people (Including one who knows tons of Trek data by heart, he even has rememerized power output numbers of different phasers) and they all say there were no Klingons at Wolf 359. I even checked Ex-Astris-Scientia's huge article on Wolf 359 and saw not one reference to Klingons, only '39 Federation ships'. Enzo Aquarius 17:30, 27 Dec 2004 (CET)
I don't believe there were Klingons at Wolf 359, either. None were seen and none were mentioned. Maybe Klingon ships were destroyed by the Borg on their way to Earth, but there was no reference to them being at the battle itself. AJHayson
- Not that this would be definitive proof that they made it to the battle, but didn't Admiral Hanson say something along the lines of "the Klingons are sending a few ships too". There isn't proof either way that Klingon ships ended up being involved, but I'm fairly sure Unity isn't the only reference to it. --Pearse 20:22, 29 November 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Constitution refit
What is this evidence on the Constitution refit? If none can be provided, it should be removed. --OuroborosCobra talk 13:50, 20 November 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Out of curiosity
Would photos taken at Star Trek The Adventure be considered a reliable source for the ships lost at Wolf 359? If so, I have a few I can upload from a display that listed all 39 of the Federation's losses. (http://www.treknation.com/reviews/star_trek_the_adventure_review.shtml)
- No, not canon. --Alan 22:20, 19 March 2008 (UTC)